Insurance agency owners: monthly books, producer payroll and taxes done for you

Free tax review

Find out what we’d handle and what it costs

Thirty minutes by phone; you leave with one written price.

Free, no obligation · Your details stay private

Each month we keep the books, match every carrier statement to its deposit, run payroll for your producers and staff, and at year end we prepare the return. Bookkeeping starts at $375 a month, quoted as a flat fee in writing before we start. Based in Santa Clarita, we work with insurance agency owners in any state.

Every carrier statement tied to its deposit Chargebacks on their own line Producer splits paid through payroll Premium money on its own line, reconciled monthly

Typical situations

Do you work with insurance agency owners like me?

Yes, we take on insurance agency owners in property and casualty or life and health, with producers and staff. A producer is a licensed salesperson who writes new business, paid a commission split: the share of each commission the agency pays the producer who wrote it. We keep an agency’s books, match every commission to the bank each month and run payroll for an agency’s producers and staff.

An independent property and casualty agency paid by several carriers

Each carrier — the insurance company that issues the policy and pays the agency its commission — sends a commission statement. The statement is the carrier’s list of what it paid, policy by policy, and the deposits land on different days. The books carry one “commission income” line built from the deposits, so nobody can tell which carrier paid what or whether a statement came up short. New-business and renewal commissions — paid on a policy’s first term and on each renewal — arrive mixed together. Each month we reconcile every carrier’s statement to the deposit it paid — that is, match the books to each statement and each bank deposit. We book commissions by carrier, with new business and renewals on separate lines. Monthly bookkeeping starts at $375 a month: how the monthly bookkeeping runs.

A life and health agency with chargebacks coming off the deposits

When a policy cancels or lapses, the carrier takes commission back — a chargeback — on a later statement, and the deposits arrive net of them. The books record only the net deposits. The commission earned and the commission taken back never show on their own, so the owner can’t see which policies cost the agency money. Producer splits get figured on commissions the agency no longer has. We book the full commission and each chargeback as separate entries from the statement, in the month the carrier takes it back, with the policy and the producer noted.

A captive agency hiring its first producer

A captive agency sells for one carrier. The owner brings on a first producer on a base salary plus a commission split, alongside a customer-service rep on hourly pay. The records are the offer letter with the split schedule, the carrier’s statements, and a plan to pay each split by bank transfer at month end. Splits paid outside payroll carry no withholding and never reach the producer’s W-2. We put the producer and the rep on payroll and pay each split as commission on the pay stub, figured from the carrier’s statement under the owner’s split schedule. Payroll starts at $95 a month: how the payroll service runs.

An independent agency paying outside producers by bank transfer

Two outside producers are paid commission splits as contractors, with no W-9s on file — a W-9 is the form a contractor signs to give a taxpayer ID. The records are the transfer history and the split sheet. In January there is no taxpayer ID to put on a 1099-NEC, the form that reports pay to someone who isn’t an employee, and nobody has looked at whether either producer should be on payroll instead. A producer who isn’t the agency’s employee goes on a 1099-NEC once the year’s payments reach the IRS’s reporting threshold. The IRS’s instructions name payments to an insurance salesperson who isn’t your employee. A signed W-9 comes before the first payment. We gather the facts on each producer and send the W-9 requests now. Then we set a producer up on payroll if the owner decides that’s right, or prepare the 1099-NEC. The decision stays the owner’s. More on our page for owners who paid workers without W-9s.

An S-corp owner who bought a retiring agent’s book of business

The agency is taxed as an S corporation — a corporation whose profit passes through to its owners’ own returns. The book of business is the policyholder relationships and the commissions they bring. What a buyer pays for customer lists and customer relationships is amortized — deducted in equal parts — over 15 years (180 months), starting the month they’re acquired. The same goes for a covenant not to compete, the seller’s promise not to compete for those customers, signed with the purchase. The records are the purchase agreement, the closing statement and the wire on the bank statement, and the whole price sits in the books as one lump with nothing set up to deduct it year by year. We record the part of the price paid for the book and any covenant on its own line, as the purchase agreement and closing statement show it, and amortize it month by month. The first year goes in Part VI of Form 4562, the IRS form for depreciation and amortization. An S-corp return starts at $850 with the owner’s personal return included: how we prepare an S-corp return.

An owner two years behind on the books

Carrier statements sit in several portals, the payroll app’s reports are the only payroll record, and premium collected on agency-billed policies — premium the agency collects from the policyholder and sends on to the carrier — was booked as income. Neither year’s return has been filed, and some payroll returns may be missing. Neither return can be prepared from real numbers until the books and payroll are rebuilt. We rebuild each year from the bank statements, each carrier’s statements and the payroll reports, move premium onto a separate line, file any missed quarterly payroll returns, then prepare both returns. Cleanup starts at $750: how a cleanup project runs.

Carrier statements

How do you keep an insurance agency’s books when every carrier pays commissions differently?

For an insurance agency owner, we reconcile each carrier’s commission statement to the deposit it paid every month, so each commission, renewal and chargeback is booked once, by carrier.

Every commission a carrier pays is income, even when no Form 1099 reports it, so we book income from each carrier’s statements, not from the net deposits or the 1099s.

We keep renewals apart from new business, carrier by carrier. Each chargeback is booked against commission income when the carrier takes it back. Agency-billed premium stays on its own line, apart from the agency’s commissions, and each month we match what was collected against what was sent on to each carrier. If a carrier sends the agency a 1099, we check its total against that carrier’s statements for the year.

Producer payroll

How do you run payroll for insurance producers paid commission splits?

We run payroll for an insurance agency’s producers and staff, with each producer’s commission split paid as commission on the pay stub.

Splits paid to a producer on payroll are wages for federal employment taxes, however they’re figured or paid. The IRS’s term for them is supplemental wages — pay such as commissions and bonuses. So we run every split through payroll with withholding, figured from the carrier statements under your split schedule.

Two federal returns go with payroll: Form 941, the quarterly federal payroll return, and Form 940, the yearly federal unemployment tax return. The 2026 W-2s go to employees by February 1, 2027. They go to the Social Security Administration by the same date, with Form W-3, the summary sent with the W-2s. We tie each Form 941 to the payroll registers and the books. We file the 2026 W-2s. Hourly pay for your office staff runs on the same payroll. Your producer agreement, not us, sets the splits and whether a split is adjusted after a chargeback.

Catch-up work

What does a catch-up look like when an insurance agency owner’s books are behind?

A catch-up rebuilds the missing months from your bank, each carrier’s commission statements and the payroll reports, then prepares the returns from the rebuilt numbers — cleanup starts at $750.

What we ask for

Bank and card statements for every account, each carrier’s commission statements for the missing months, the payroll reports, every W-9 you have, and the record of premium collected and sent on for agency-billed policies.

How the cleanup runs

Each carrier’s statements matched to the bank deposits, statement by statement, so each commission and each chargeback is booked once. Premium collected and sent on moved onto a separate line. Each producer’s wages and commissions and each staff member’s wages rebuilt from the payroll reports, and missed quarterly payroll returns and the annual federal unemployment return rebuilt from them. Payments to producers paid as contractors tied to a person before any 1099 goes out. A purchased book set up on its own line from the month acquired. Unfiled years taken oldest first — a few weeks.

What you get

The rebuilt years, the returns prepared from reconciled numbers, and quarterly estimates — the tax payments made four times a year — figured from your real numbers.

Cleanup is billed half to start and the balance on delivery — see how a cleanup project runs.

The monthly close

What do you check every month in an insurance agency’s books?

Every month we close the books and check each carrier’s statement against the bank, the chargebacks, the premium money, the producer splits and the payroll filings before the report goes out.

  • Each carrier’s statement tied to its deposit
  • New-business and renewal commissions by carrier, in dollars
  • Chargeback lines checked against the carrier’s statement, with the policy and producer noted
  • Premium collected on agency-billed policies against what was sent to each carrier
  • Each producer’s commissions tied to the statements they were paid from
  • Payroll tax deposits tied to the payroll register
  • Each contractor producer’s running total against the W-9 on file
  • The month’s amortization on a purchased book, if there is one

Each month you get the P&L (the profit and loss statement), the balance sheet and a short note on what needs attention — see how the monthly bookkeeping runs.

California

What’s different for an insurance agency owner in California?

In California, four things change for an insurance agency owner: payroll registration and quarterly returns with the Employment Development Department (EDD), a state report for producers paid as contractors, no qualified business income (QBI) deduction on the state return, and letters from the Franchise Tax Board (FTB). The QBI deduction is a federal deduction for part of a pass-through business’s qualified income.

  • Payroll with the EDD. An agency that pays more than $100 in wages in a quarter registers with the EDD within 15 days, then files the DE 9 and DE 9C, California’s quarterly payroll returns, electronically each quarter. We do the registration, file both returns and report new and rehired employees to the EDD within 20 days of the start of work.
  • Producers paid as contractors go on California’s own report. A contractor who is an individual, a sole proprietor or a single-member LLC also goes on the DE 542, California’s report of contractors paid, to the EDD within 20 days of the payment or contract that brings that contractor over California’s reporting threshold. We check each producer paid as a contractor against it.
  • No QBI deduction on the state return. California doesn’t follow the federal QBI deduction, so it doesn’t reduce an owner’s California taxable income. We figure the California return without it.
  • FTB letters. If California’s FTB sends a letter about a return, we handle it, as we handle IRS letters: how we handle IRS and FTB letters.

Pricing

What do the books, payroll and the return cost in 2026?

In 2026, bookkeeping for an insurance agency owner starts at $375 a month, payroll from $95 a month for producers and staff, the return alone from $650 for a one-owner agency on Schedule C (the business page of your personal return) or from $850 for an S-corp or partnership return with the owner’s personal return included, and a cleanup from $750.

W-2 and 1099 filing on their own, without monthly payroll, starts at $95; producers’ and staff members’ W-2s are included when we run payroll. With two or more owners, the other owners’ personal returns are quoted on the call. Each added carrier, producer or company is priced inside the same written quote.

Reconciling the carrier statements, separating new business from renewals, tracking chargebacks, the premium-money reconciliation, producer split reports, setting each producer’s federal unemployment tax treatment, the amortization schedule for a purchased book, collecting W-9s and keeping each contractor producer’s running total sit inside the quote. What moves a quote: how many carriers pay the agency and how many statements arrive a month; whether you collect premium for any carrier; how many producers and staff you pay, how — salary, commission splits or both, payroll or contractor — and how often; whether you bought a book of business; the number of bank and card accounts and transactions; sole proprietor, LLC, partnership or S corporation, and how many owners; how far behind the books are and whether payroll returns were missed; and the states your producers and staff work in. Books, payroll and the return are each a flat fee quoted in writing before we start.

Books

from $375/mo

  • Each carrier’s statement reconciled to its deposit
  • New business apart from renewals, chargebacks on their own line
  • Agency-billed premium matched each month to what each carrier was sent
  • Monthly P&L, balance sheet and a short note

Payroll

from $95/mo

  • Pay runs weekly, biweekly or monthly, commission splits on the pay stub
  • Direct deposit and pay stubs, new-hire reporting
  • Federal deposits and the 941 and 940; California’s DE 9 and DE 9C
  • Year-end W-2s — how the payroll service runs

The return alone

from $650

  • A one-owner agency’s self-employed return on Schedule C
  • From $850 for an S-corp or partnership return — the owner’s personal return included
  • Quarterly estimates from your real numbers — how we prepare the return

The quote is the price.

Book my free 30-minute call

How it works

What happens after you book?

The engagement letter goes out during the free 30-minute call, and signing brings a short onboarding call, a portal invite and a short checklist.

The 30-minute call

We ask how many carriers pay the agency and how their statements arrive, whether you collect premium for any carrier, how many producers and staff you pay and how, which W-9s you have, whether you bought a book of business, your entity and owners, and how far behind the books are. It ends with one flat fee for the work we’d take on, quoted in writing before we start.

The engagement letter

Sent during the call and signed when you’re ready. Signing books a short onboarding call, and the secure-portal invite comes from that call.

Access and documents

The portal invite, read-only bank feeds or access to your current books, and each carrier’s commission statements for 2026; the producer split schedule you use; the payroll reports and the quarterly payroll returns filed; every W-9 you have; the record of premium collected and sent on for agency-billed policies; the purchase agreement and closing statement for any book you bought (we read them only for the price, the date and what was bought); and the returns you filed most recently. We send a short checklist so nothing is missed.

Behind first, then monthly

If the books are behind, the cleanup comes first, then the first monthly close.

You see the return before it’s filed

Half the return fee starts the work, and the balance is due before e-file. You review the return before anything is filed, and an extension is free if April gets tight.

Communication

You’ll know where the books, payroll and the return stand.

The person who answers the phone is on the same team that keeps your books and prepares your return.

The same-day rule

Call or email during business hours and you’ll hear back the same day — all twelve months.

Agency owners are welcome

One carrier or many, a first producer or a full roster — the free call ends with a straight answer on whether we’re the right fit.

Admitted to practice before the IRS

Our team of IRS representation specialists is admitted to practice before the IRS. If an IRS letter shows up, forward it — we handle it.

NT

The N&T Tax & Advisory Group team

For an insurance agency owner, we keep the books, run producer and staff payroll and prepare the return from the same numbers. One team, reachable all year.

Bookkeeping · Tax preparation · Tax planning · IRS representation · Direct line: (661) 554-4495

Reviews

Rated 5.0 on Google

★★★★★  Twelve reviews, every one five stars, every one verifiable. Read all of them on Google →

"Alex helped me resolve a complicated tax situation that had been causing me a lot of stress. He was extremely knowledgeable, responsive, and efficient throughout the entire process."

Kevin B. — via Google

"Working with Alex was straightforward. I hadn't looked at my books all year, but he made my life easy and handled the whole profit and loss at the end of the year so I could get my taxes done."

Levon B. — via Google

"I came to this company with previous tax years and bookkeeping that were done incorrectly. They're very knowledgeable about what they do and help me get everything in order at a very reasonable price."

Sayra A. — via Google

Where we work

Do you work with insurance agency owners outside California?

Yes — based in Santa Clarita, we work with insurance agency owners remotely in any state. Documents move through the secure portal, and calls and screen share walk through the monthly report. If your agency has producers or staff in another state, we work to that state’s payroll and filing rules and price it into your quote.

Anywhere in the US Santa Clarita Los Angeles San Fernando Valley

What we don’t do

We don’t advise on insurance licensing, the Department of Insurance’s rules for premium accounts, carrier and agency contracts, errors-and-omissions coverage, or what a book of business is worth or how its purchase is priced. Producer agreements, wage-and-hour rules for commission pay, legal advice, and reviewed, compiled or audited statements are outside our work, and we give no insurance advice of any kind.

FAQ

What should an insurance agency owner ask before booking?

Should my producers be on payroll or paid on a 1099?

Whether a producer is an employee or a contractor turns on who had the right to control the work, not on what you call the arrangement or how the pay is measured. The IRS looks at behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship, with no set number of factors, and either the agency or the producer can ask the IRS to decide on Form SS-8. A producer who is a contractor and was paid $2,000 or more for services in 2026 gets a 1099-NEC by February 1, 2027; for payments made in 2025 and earlier the line was $600. We go through those facts with you on the call and you make the decision, and we tell you when a case needs an employment attorney.

Do I owe federal unemployment tax on a producer paid only commission?

Under federal law, a producer’s work for the agency as an insurance agent isn’t covered by the federal unemployment tax — FUTA, the tax reported on Form 940 — when all of that work is paid solely by commission. A producer on payroll who also gets a salary or hourly pay is covered, and the agency still withholds federal income tax and pays Social Security and Medicare tax on an employee’s commissions. We set each producer’s pay type so Form 940 counts only the pay FUTA covers, check it whenever a pay plan changes, and handle your state’s payroll taxes under that state’s own rules.

Is an insurance agency a specified service business for the QBI deduction?

The qualified business income (QBI) deduction rules list service fields, called specified service businesses, whose deduction is limited at higher incomes; the brokerage field doesn’t include services provided by insurance agents and brokers. That deduction covers part of a pass-through business’s qualified income, and the limit applies only above $201,750 of 2026 taxable income ($403,500 on a joint return), in full at $276,750 ($553,500 joint). The regulation lists other fields too, among them financial services such as managing wealth, advising clients on their finances and developing retirement plans, so before the return we go through what your agency earns its commissions and fees for against that list.

A carrier charged back a commission I reported last year. Where does that go on my return?

A charged-back commission you reported last year may be deductible for the year the carrier takes it back, in most cases as a business expense on Schedule C for a one-owner agency. That is the IRS’s repayment rule in Publication 525, its guide to taxable and nontaxable income: an amount you repay that you included in income in an earlier year is, in most cases, deducted on the same form or schedule you reported it on. If you paid a producer who isn’t your employee a commission that’s subject to repayment, and it wasn’t repaid during the year, it still counts toward that producer’s 1099-NEC total. We book the chargeback from the carrier’s statement when it’s taken back, so the books and the return show it in the year it happened, and an S-corp or partnership return follows those books.

My agency’s books are months behind. Can you catch them up?

Yes, we catch up an insurance agency’s books: cleanup starts at $750, and unfiled years are taken oldest first, with any missed quarterly payroll returns filed along the way. Each carrier’s statements and each past year are priced in the quote. Our cleanup page shows how the project runs.

Should my insurance agency be an LLC or an S-corp?

An S-corp is a tax election an LLC can also make, so the choice is about how the agency is taxed. A California LLC owes the $800 annual tax, plus a fee once its total California income — gross income plus the cost of goods sold, not profit — reaches $250,000, and an S corporation pays at least California’s $800 minimum franchise tax plus a tax on its California income. We answer that question free on the 30-minute call, with your salary and payroll costs modeled on the agency’s numbers, and the election and setup start at $595 only if you go ahead; our entity-selection page shows how we compare the options.

Ready to hand off the statements, the payroll and the return?

One free 30-minute call. You’ll leave knowing what we’d handle and what it costs — whether or not you hire us.

Book my free 30-minute call

Rather talk now? Call (661) 554-4495 — reach us during business hours and you’ll hear back the same day.